““While her win over Tafoya, who was backed by President Donald Trump, is a positive for Democrats in their pursuit of power in the upper chamber, it's not necessarily a negative for Republicans, given that the seat was already blue.” — Fox News, Alex Miller, Nov. 4, 2026”
The claim: ““While her win over Tafoya, who was backed by President Donald Trump, is a positive for Democrats in their pursuit of power in the upper chamber, it's not necessarily a negative for Republicans, given that the seat was already blue.” — Fox News, Alex Miller, Nov. 4, 2026”
Why we rated it this way: The Senate's Minnesota roster lists Democrat Tina Smith in the Class 2 seat since Jan. 3, 2018, after Democrat Al Franken, so Flanagan's win keeps a Democratic seat rather than flipping one. The same roster shows the last Republican to hold it was Norm Coleman, who served 2003 to 2009 after winning in 2002. Fox's own story also notes Flanagan beat Michele Tafoya, which a Tafoya concession supports.
See the evidenceWhat would change our rating: A Senate record showing the seat was held by a Republican or independent going into the 2026 election, or certified Minnesota results showing Tafoya won, would move this verdict.
Our read
The Senate's Minnesota roster lists Democrat Tina Smith in the Class 2 seat since Jan. 3, 2018, after Democrat Al Franken, so Flanagan's win keeps a Democratic seat rather than flipping one. The same roster shows the last Republican to hold it was Norm Coleman, who served 2003 to 2009 after winning in 2002. Fox's own story also notes Flanagan beat Michele Tafoya, which a Tafoya concession supports.
Broadcast
Picture to come
Nov 4, 2026, 11:10 PM CST
Sources
Script
Narration script. If a face or a voice delivers this, the anchor is synthetic.
Late Check. Fox News says Peggy Flanagan's Minnesota win wasn't a Republican loss because the seat was already blue. The Senate's roster shows Democrat Tina Smith has held it since 2018, and Republicans last won it in 2002. Verdict: matches the record.
Corrections
None on file.