““Democrat Annie Andrews will win the U.S. Senate race in South Carolina, CNN’s Decision Desk projects, defeating Sen. Darline Graham and flipping a seat that Republicans have held for nearly three decades.” — CNN, Dianne Gallagher, Nov. 3, 2026 (CNN Newsource story as published by KESQ)”
The claim: ““Democrat Annie Andrews will win the U.S. Senate race in South Carolina, CNN’s Decision Desk projects, defeating Sen. Darline Graham and flipping a seat that Republicans have held for nearly three decades.” — CNN, Dianne Gallagher, Nov. 3, 2026 (CNN Newsource story as published by KESQ)”
Why we rated it this way: The Senate's South Carolina roster shows the Class 2 seat Andrews won passed from Strom Thurmond (1956-2003) to Lindsey Graham (2003-2026) to Darline Graham, and the Senate's party-switch list shows Thurmond became a Republican on Sept. 16, 1964, so Republicans have held the seat for about 62 years, not nearly three decades. The 28-year figure matches a different fact in the same story: the last Democrat to win a South Carolina Senate race was Fritz Hollings in 1998. The projection itself and Andrews being the state's first woman elected to the Senate are consistent with the roster.
See the evidenceWhat would change our rating: A Senate record showing the Class 2 seat was held by a Democrat at some point after 1964 would move this to Matches record; a CNN correction clarifying it meant the last Democratic Senate win would resolve the discrepancy.
Our read
The Senate's South Carolina roster shows the Class 2 seat Andrews won passed from Strom Thurmond (1956-2003) to Lindsey Graham (2003-2026) to Darline Graham, and the Senate's party-switch list shows Thurmond became a Republican on Sept. 16, 1964, so Republicans have held the seat for about 62 years, not nearly three decades. The 28-year figure matches a different fact in the same story: the last Democrat to win a South Carolina Senate race was Fritz Hollings in 1998. The projection itself and Andrews being the state's first woman elected to the Senate are consistent with the roster.
Broadcast
Picture to come
Nov 3, 2026, 11:10 PM CST
Sources
Script
Narration script. If a face or a voice delivers this, the anchor is synthetic.
Late Check. CNN says Annie Andrews flipped a South Carolina Senate seat Republicans held for nearly three decades. The Senate's records show that seat has been Republican since Strom Thurmond switched parties in 1964, about 62 years. Verdict: contradicted by the record.
Corrections
None on file.